250 homes to be demolished for 650 new ones

[claybro]

To be clear, I am not against high density zones. But these must be near high frequency train stations, preferably including local shops, childcare and maybe even a small pub or social facility.. none of which we are getting with these middle suburb proposals. It’s lazy and cheap, and we have learnt nothing in the last 50 -70 years where these developement become ghettos.. except now with the added issues of an apparent complete lack of being able to control the unruly elements in society.

[Llessur2002]

But these must be near high frequency train stations, preferably including local shops, childcare and maybe even a small pub or social facility.

I think this is pretty much the ethos of the 15 minute city concept.

[SouthAussie94]

To be clear, I am not against high density zones. But these must be near high frequency train stations, preferably including local shops, childcare and maybe even a small pub or social facility.. none of which we are getting with these middle suburb proposals. It’s lazy and cheap, and we have learnt nothing in the last 50 -70 years where these developement become ghettos.. except now with the added issues of an apparent complete lack of being able to control the unruly elements in society.

What came first, the chicken or the egg?

[rev]

But these must be near high frequency train stations, preferably including local shops, childcare and maybe even a small pub or social facility.

I think this is pretty much the ethos of the 15 minute city concept.

We used to have small corner deli's and fish and chip shops throughout the suburbs. Where are they all now?

It's all a bit like a European city, high density multi-level residential, with retail tenancies at ground level, be it a pharmacy or cafe or take away shop or other retail.
I guess we're about to find out in the near future if it will be sustainable in Adelaide.

[Mpol02]

Isn’t our current state government against this though? I’m confused why is this happening

[ChillyPhilly]

But these must be near high frequency train stations, preferably including local shops, childcare and maybe even a small pub or social facility.

I think this is pretty much the ethos of the 15 minute city concept.

We used to have small corner deli's and fish and chip shops throughout the suburbs. Where are they all now?

It's all a bit like a European city, high density multi-level residential, with retail tenancies at ground level, be it a pharmacy or cafe or take away shop or other retail.
I guess we're about to find out in the near future if it will be sustainable in Adelaide.

Local delis have been wiped out by OTR and other junk service stations.

[rev]

I think this is pretty much the ethos of the 15 minute city concept.

We used to have small corner deli's and fish and chip shops throughout the suburbs. Where are they all now?

It's all a bit like a European city, high density multi-level residential, with retail tenancies at ground level, be it a pharmacy or cafe or take away shop or other retail.
I guess we're about to find out in the near future if it will be sustainable in Adelaide.

Local delis have been wiped out by OTR and other junk service stations.

They were starting to disappear long before an OTR popped up in every suburb.
And the local chicken shop/fish & chip shop started to vanish well before the healthy eating trends started.

It's kind of like a full circle in a way with these new higher density developments now, with local coffee shops integrated.

[SBD]

We used to have small corner deli's and fish and chip shops throughout the suburbs. Where are they all now?

It's all a bit like a European city, high density multi-level residential, with retail tenancies at ground level, be it a pharmacy or cafe or take away shop or other retail.
I guess we're about to find out in the near future if it will be sustainable in Adelaide.

Local delis have been wiped out by OTR and other junk service stations.

They were starting to disappear long before an OTR popped up in every suburb.
And the local chicken shop/fish & chip shop started to vanish well before the healthy eating trends started.

It's kind of like a full circle in a way with these new higher density developments now, with local coffee shops integrated.

(Catching up in a few busy weeks)
As far as I can tell, my local chicken/fish and chip shop is owned by a family who might have two or three in other suburbs, but not a big chain. My local pizza shop is part of a loose chain - the owner's brothers also own pizza shops a few suburbs away.

I suspect that the demise of corner grocery shops should be blamed on us - the customers - not just the competition. We (collectively) could have continued to use our 1950s local shops instead of drifting to the larger supermarkets. In turn the small family-owned shops either closed or grew, and joined forces. Foodland and IGA stores are still independently owned, but the successful ones are a lot bigger than they were fifty years ago and some owners run mini-chains. Drakes was one of those until it grew big enough to leave the Foodland "family". South Australia seems to still have a lot more of these kinds of competitive shops than most other states.

OTR, X-convenience and AM/PM have grown to fill a need that overlaps but is slightly different. The world will look different again in fifty more years when bulk portable liquid fuel stops being a daily necessity.